Monday, May 4, 2015

The 3% Problem

I recently enrolled in a MOOC on edX called Making Sense of Climate Science Denial, offered by the University of Queensland, Australia. 


"Oh, so you're a 3-percenter, eh?"

I churned through the first week's videos and learned an interesting fact: about 97% of climate scientists agree that human activity is causing significant climate change. The course presents this as a "gateway fact," one that prompts people to accept climate change as a reality more predictably than other arguments that might provoke more politically-charged responses.

I imagined sharing this newfound nugget with skeptical acquaintances thusly:
"I don't believe any of that global warming garbage." 
"Oh, so you're a 3-percenter, eh?" 
"A what?" 
"A 3-percenter. You're with the 3-percent of climate scientists who don't believe that we're heating up the planet."

Boom. Sassy, right? Admittedly, "pedantic" is probably a better description. Don't judge me too harshly. But the point is, it's a really good point. 

Right?

Yet, perplexingly, I don't actually know that 97% of climate scientists believe in climate change per se. I know that the nice man with the cool accent said so on the Internet. But I don't actually know that he's a professor at the University of Queensland. I don't even know if there is a University of Queensland. I mean, I could make a logo and get a domain name easily enough. . .

Even if he is a real professor at a real university citing a real study, I don't actually have any idea whether it's credible or just a bunch of hogwash. I just trust that he's telling the truth.


Why? Laziness, I suppose. Let's call it the Path of Least Resistance Heuristic, or more colloquially, the 3% problem.

It's not exactly a cognitive bias (like the Availability Heuristic), because I'm judging contexts and probabilities more holistically and rationally, but it's not exactly watertight, either.

There are decent reasons to believe that this gentleman is not straight-up lying to thousands of people. A move like that could permanently hamper his credibility as a scientist and as an educator. Further, edX seems like a reliable platform, since MIT and Harvard (universities of well-cultivated prestige and reputation) choose to host courses there. So, weighing my confidence in what I know about this man and the position of his claims within a system of academic and social checks & balances, I feel fairly confident that he is making an accurate representation of the facts.

Still, it kinda bothers me that I don't know for myself. So I get to thinking—what else don't I know? Turns out there's quite a bit. 


"Australia." Allegedly.

I don't know. . .

  • that Australia is a real place.
  • that calling Geico could save me 15% or more on my car insurance.
  • that Zane was really ever part of One Direction.
  • that I am actually going to die some day.

In all of these cases, I have no certainty, no confirmation of my theory of the truth. I have several friends who say they're from Australia, but no proof. But here's where it gets interesting.

It turns out that my 3% problem is actually not mine, and it's actually not a problem— it's a razor. Occam's razor, to be precise. (I have Michael Stevens of Vsauce to thank for explaining that one in "Did the Past Really Happen?"). As Wikipedia puts it, if you've got two hypotheses that predict outcomes equally well, stick with the one that requires fewer assumptions.

Given the claims of friends and random YouTube strangers (and Crocodile Hunter Steve Irwin) that they are from a distant continent known as "Australia," and the consistency with which said continent has appeared on ostensibly reputable maps throughout my lifetime, and its pervasive representation in realistic fiction and historical accounts, I must either conclude that Australia is in fact a real place, or that a great many people are lying to me very consistently. Like thousands and thousands of people. Maybe millions. Since I can't see any reason for them to do such a thing, I'll stick with the simpler, less assumptive hypothesis that this purported "land down under" is indeed a solid hunk of rock and not a giant hoax.

Same goes for climate change—I may be less sure about it than I am about Australia, but not by much. The people who seem to know seem to agree. 

Now, I'm not saying that a majority vote makes the truth. We need healthy skepticism, because sometimes large groups of people agree on things that are just plain wrong. Like the merits of enslaving other people. Or the need for genocide.

But in this case, I think they're on to something that's worth looking into. And to quote Smashmouth:
The ice we skate is gettin' pretty thin. 
The water's gettin' warm so you might as well swim.
So, no worries, mate. Jump on in.

No comments:

Post a Comment